Friday, 9 March 2012

The Influence of Soviet Montage in "Hanna"

According to Eisenstein, there are 5 types of montage: Metric, Rhythmic, Tonal, Overtonal and Intellectual montage. In “Hanna”, the director has used the elements of overtonal montage and intellectual in the movie.

Overtonal montage element occur the scene where Hanna was in the hotel. When Hanna walks into the hotel room, she is curious with the electronic devices such as light tubes, kettle, television, fan and etc.  She plays around with the light switch, the hotel manager switch on the television and kettle for her. Hanna touch the kettle when the water is boiled but the surface of the kettle is hot and Hanna gets scald. She tries to close the kettle but she unable to close it, then she start panic because all the electronic devices are out of control. The director use overtonal montage which he cuts the shots of spinning fan, ringing phone, boiling kettle, shower tap and other irrelevant moving object such as helicopter, armies (which showing on television) to show out Hanna’s feeling of panic, anxiety and nervous.

The second montage style be used in this movie is intellectual montage. Hanna accidentally gets her DNA report which stated her has abnormal DNA and this make her confuse with her own background. She went to the internet café to online and checks the information about DNA.

The scene shows that the keywords -“DNA” follow by other words such as “interference” and “intervention into mothers uterus”, it helps audience to related those terms and inference Hanna’s background.  The visual which conduct a series of pictures related to the human experiment, for example experimental rat, DNA chart, a experiment process of test tube inject into cell and state “unsanctioned by scientific community”, a drawing which a bird monster eating a human and birds fly out from human anus, human testing about genetic, finger prints, human development graph and baby born short clips. The elements mention above is to summarize the background of Hanna and shows Hanna carry different DNA with normal people.

Besides, Hanna also search the name of her dad – ‘Erik Heller’, the result of her searching shows that he is related to Hanna’s mother murder cases. The iris of Hanna’s father (Erik) is different form Hanna’s iris. It shows that Hanna has different DNA with her father and she might not biological relations.

Another montage that use by the director is on the scene after Hanna turns on the signal decoder device, then it cut to the scene of Marissa’s bedroom. In the scene it shows Marissa is freshen up herself then it cut back again to Hanna’s house.

Some significant montage that can found in this movie is the scene which shows the soldiers come to Hanna’s house to arrest Erik. There are intercut shots between the close up of Hanna’s eye and a group of soldiers coming towards her house.     

19 comments:

  1. I think visuals aids such as pictures from the movie would make it easier for the readers to understand.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for your suggestion. We will improved our content soon. Hope you enjoy of reading our blog.

      Delete
  2. It would be better if there were screen shots from the film to explain the types of montages. Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. We will consider your suggestion and update our blog very soon.But anyway, we are appreciate your suggestion. it will make our blog more informative. thank you very much.

      Delete
  3. I'm agree with the comments above. It will be better for me to understand more if the screen shot of the montage scene that you described above is included as it might helps me ta have a clearer picture of what you are explaining. thankz

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you for viewing our blog. Your suggestion we will consider and update our blog soon. hope you will read our blog agian after we doing the update and changes.We are appreciated your comment and opinion.

      Delete
  4. I think you skipped the historical background, film list and directors of the movement that you are doing about. There are also some grammatical errors. Reference list can be included to make your post more credible. Maybe visuals such as screen shots, pictures or videos could be included would be an added advantage.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. hi, Sher Maine, we do the historical background, film list and director of soviet montage. The post is under February. Hope you will enjoy to read our blog. About the grammatival error, we will appreciate you are telling us and we will improve and update soon.

      Delete
  5. This article provides a very detail explanation of Montage usage in the film “Hanna”. However, perhaps you should include more different examples by other directors to show more various influences of soviet montage towards contemporary film instead of only specific on “Hanna”.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Warrior Fighter, we need to clarify why we only using "Hanna" in our explanation.It is because we want to show how deep the soviet montage influential in the contemporary film.But your suggestion will be our consideration when we update our blog. Thank you and appreciate your suggestion.

      Delete
  6. Quite detailed explanation on the film "Hanna" but perhaps, instead of only focusing on this movie, you could include more and yup, cite the examples from the scenes which you think are related to the particular influences of Soviet Montage throughout your analysis. I agree with most of the comments given above, where you should include some screen shots, pictures, or videos so that it is not only for us to understand your analysis, but also we can gain deeper understanding on the things you write. And remember include your reference lists as if we as an audience, would like to find more about your analysis, we could refer to your references. Overall, was quite okay. Thanks!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Film Dissections, your comment we will appreciate.As we mention to warrior fighter, we just only focus on "Hanna" one movie just because we want to show how this movement influence the contemporary in deep.We will consider your suggestion, we will update our blog soon. Hope you will come and read it again. Thank you.

      Delete
  7. It would be better if can provide some visual aids for better understanding. Besides "Hanna", can you give us more other examples from other films which influences by Soviet Montage for comparison?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi,If visual aids will make you more understanding, we will consider this and update it soon. About the more examples from other films, we will consider your suggestion. Because in this moment, we only want to show how deep the soviet montage influential a film. Therefore, the comparison, we will doing more research on it and update it soon. Thank you your advise, we are appreciate it.

      Delete
  8. I agreed with comments above where visual aids such as pictures or short clips can be inserted so that we can easily understand. Besides that, I suggested you to put on more examples rather than just one so that we can compare and see the similarities for Soviet Montage that applied in all the films.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, Alvin, the visual aids we will update soon. We just focus on "Hanna" this movie is show how deep the soviet montage influence a movie. Just like what we reply to the comment above, we will doing more research and doing comparison soon to make all of you clear about the movement applied in contemporary films.

      Thank you your advise and comment. We are appreciate. Hope you will keep reading our blog in future. Thank you.

      Delete
  9. What are the other influence on the movie Hanna? Can you give more movies that has Soviet montage and also some clips to watch in details? thank you.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi, sorry that not clear about your question. You mean other influence on the movie Hanna is in what aspect? The other film movement? The movies that has Soviet montage such requiem for a dream ,The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. About the clip to watch in detail will update soon. Thank you your suggestion.

      Delete
  10. Instead of criticizing the blog, Google the movie and see for yourselves. The institute of instant gratification is to wide spread with wanting everything in your face. The Internet is so vast that one can google and watch the movie fir a clearer understanding.

    ReplyDelete